Scholarship Judging Criteria
At the North Star STEM Foundation, we believe that understanding STEM is important, but being able to share that understanding with others is just as valuable. Every submission is evaluated using the same 100-point rubric across four categories.
Scientific Accuracy — 30 Points (30%)
Does your video communicate scientifically accurate information?
Judges will consider:
- Whether the scientific explanations are correct.
- Whether the video demonstrates an understanding of the chosen STEM topic.
- Whether claims and demonstrations are supported by established scientific principles or reliable evidence.
What we’re looking for: A video that teaches viewers something scientifically correct and meaningful.
Clarity of Communication — 30 Points (30%)
Can someone unfamiliar with your topic understand your explanation?
Judges will consider:
- How clearly the topic is introduced and explained.
- Whether complex ideas are presented in accessible language.
- Whether the video follows a logical, easy-to-follow structure.
- Whether visuals and/or narration help viewers understand the concept.
What we’re looking for: A video that makes STEM understandable, even to someone encountering the topic for the first time.
Creativity & Engagement — 30 Points (30%)
Does your video capture attention and present STEM in an interesting way?
Judges will consider:
- The originality of the presentation.
- Whether the opening captures the viewer’s interest.
- Creative use of experiments, demonstrations, illustrations, storytelling, or other visual techniques.
- Whether the video maintains the audience’s attention throughout.
What we’re looking for: A memorable, engaging approach that makes viewers excited to learn.
Personal Connection — 10 Points (10%)
Does your video connect STEM to your personal interests or life in Alaska?
Judges will consider:
- Whether the topic has a meaningful connection to the student’s interests, experiences, or community.
- Whether the video highlights STEM concepts relevant to Alaska.
- Whether the student demonstrates genuine curiosity or personal enthusiasm for the topic.
What we’re looking for: A video that makes STEM personal, demonstrating how scientific concepts connect to the student or to life in Alaska.
What DOESN’T Affect Your Score
You don’t need expensive equipment or professional production experience to create a competitive submission.
Judges will not award additional points simply because you use:
- Professional cameras or microphones.
- Expensive editing software.
- Elaborate filming locations or equipment.
- A large social media following.
- Previous STEM competitions or research experience.
Tips for a Strong Submission
Start with a question. Give viewers a reason to be curious about your topic.
Focus on one concept. You only have 60–90 seconds, so prioritize a clear explanation over covering too much information.
Show, don’t just tell. A simple experiment, demonstration, or drawing can make a complicated concept easier to understand.
Check your science. Research your topic using reliable sources and make sure your explanations are accurate.
Teach your audience something. Think about what you want viewers to remember after watching your video.